I suspect that Analytics Counter displays info on the wrong site. How can I check for which site it is showing statistics, or how can I reconnect to the right webpage?
If you connected Google Analytics Counter plugin to the Google Analytics Account that has several properties, then all these properties (websites) stats will be available to display in Analytics Counter plugin.
In order to check if the plugin shows statistics of the desired website, do the following:
1) Go to the main page of Analytics Counter plugin at your wordpress dashboard;
2) Open Analytics Counter Settings
3)Select Site for which you want to see statistics and Save changes.
If you want to reconnect Analytics Counter plugin to another GA account, follow this guide